Whatever you might want to say about Microsoft calling Silverlight “crossplatform” and not making a version for Linux, you have to give them credit for what they did leading up to Obama’s inauguraiton.
Basically, they worked with Novell to improve Moonlight, an open-source implementation of Silverlight for Linux, to the point where Linux users could watch the inauguration. While I was away from my own computer during the inauguraiton and had to suffer through an audio stream from Fox poorly synced with a jerky video stream from CNN, commenters appear to be reporting that everything worked just fine in the end for Linux users. We should give a lot of credit to Microsoft for caring that all operating systems were compatible with the live stream.
Ultimately, though, it was the right thing to do not just because of the good PR, but also for the Silverlight standard. Standards are standard because they are well-supported by the major players. Even if Linux can’t compare to Windows in market share numbers, Silverlight has a much better chance if it is well supported on Linux. If Microsoft chooses to do this by supporting an open implementation of Silverlight, that is even better.
It is really impressive and, quite frankly, suprising that Microsoft went to the effort of supporting an open-source implementation of their standard. This is certainly a move in the right direction for Microsoft.
Related posts:
Why do we even NEED Silverlight, Moonlight, or (for that matter) Mono? We have Flash, JavaScript, and Java!
The ONLY long-term purpose for Moonlight/Mono is to sneak Microsoft’s proprietary code and encumbrances into the F/OSS Big Tent–just like the old saying about the camel’s nose…
I use Windows–a little–but it has NOTHING to add to Linux that we can’t do for ourselves. The Microsoft strings are the ties that bind–and have the potential to strangle Linux. I’ve been watching MS for over thirty years and I’m pretty sure that’s what they want.
~~ ScienceMikey
I would prefer not having websites using MS Silverlight at all.
Can anyone guarantee to me that MS will continue to “work with Novell to improve Moonlight, an open-source implementation of Silverlight for Linux, to the point where Linux users could watch the inauguration” for ever? No, noone. Thats the end of this discussion
they had to do it simply because with such an event they didn’t want people complaining, getting bad press and then getting into trouble again (specially with the white house..), since they advertised their product as crossplatform, universal web-streaming format.
seriously they don’t deserve much merit, it was their job to do so (at least this time), it was not something out of heart.