Modify Colors
Where Are The Brainstorm Clones?
If you haven’t noticed, I am a big fan of Ubuntu Brainstorm, particularly the concept of allowing the end-user to propose ideas in an open and transparent way. One of the things I have been most hoping for, though, was the Brainstorm clones. Unfortunately, they have not come yet.
Quite a while ago, Dell introduced IdeaStorm, a site where people could submit ideas and other people could vote on them. It was as a result of this that Dell now sells Ubuntu pre-installed on some computers (like the one I am typing this on). I don’t know if Ubuntu Brainstorm was officially based on IdeaStorm, but is certainly does look (*ahem*) inspired by IdeaStorm.
After Dell and Ubuntu both adopted this form of user feedback, I was really hoping that it would catch on among other open-source projects. Imagine if every project had their own version of Brainstorm, so that you could submit ideas to any project. A while ago when Brainstorm as still young, Brainstorm project member Nicolas Deschildre even discussed the idea of the a so-called “decentralized brainstorm,” where all of these separate Brainstorms could share ideas between them.
The problem is, these Brainstorms clones just have not appeared. I am not aware of any other major open-source project using a system like this. For me, this is a big disappointment. I felt, and still feel, that Brainstorm-like approaches hold the potential to serve as an amazing platform for bringing the average user into the development and creation process. With an effective Brainstorm system, a project can truly be made by the users, even if only a small group of people can actually do the coding.
I would love to know why more projects have not adopted something like Ubuntu Brainstorm. Is it just too early? Are they not convinced it will help them in the long run? I have no idea, but I would really love to see more use of Brainstorm-like systems in open-source projects.
Related posts:
- KDE Launches KDE Brainstorm Yesterday the KDE project launched their own version of Ubuntu...
- Ubuntu Brainstorm: The Perfect Combination of Open-Source and Democracy Today Ubuntu announced something that I have thought they should...
- Future of Brainstorm A few days ago in Brilliant Brainstorms #9 I suggested,...
- Brainstorm Off to a Fast Start, Will it keep up the pace? Just 3 days since the launch of Ubuntu Brainstorm, the...
- The New Ubuntu Brainstorm The new and much improved version of Ubuntu Brainstorm, Ubuntu’s...
Hey,
Same reaction here, I’m quite surprised of this situation. If I except Blenderstorm, a old modified version of Ubuntu Brainstorm, and of course Ubuntu, I am aware of no open source project using it so far. I have seen some discussion about it on some forums, mainly by users, but this was never implemented. On the contrary, I get much requests from companies. The Stockholm airport Brainstorm should go live soon, and another big big name later.
I see two reasons why Open Source projects are not using brainstorm systems:
- Developers do not want extra pressure. They have the freedom to choose what to work on next, and they do not want to be told what to do by users. It’s basically the scratch-your-own-itch thing. I guess this reason’s importance varies from developer to developer.
- Lack of tools. Besides Ideatorrent, the Ubuntu Brainstorm engine, which is still marked as beta, and maybe suffering the fact that it’s a Drupal module requiring PostgreSQL, there is no other built-solution.
Now, I’m wondering if setting up a Wordpress.com-service-like may be worth the necessary work : free hosting of IdeaTorrent instances with ads…