Modify Colors

Default Reverse Brown Dark Blue

Archive

Advertisement

Recently, Richard Stallman called cloud computing “worse than stupidity.” His argument for this view is that, by giving your data away to the host of the web application you are using, you are essentially giving up all rights to that data. After all, they own it and there is little you can do to stop them from doing whatever they want with that data.

I agree with Stallman that there is a potential risk to putting your data in a closed-source, closed standards web application. I do not believe, however, that it is fair to say that web applications in general are a data trap, or, for that matter, in any way something to avoid.

If a web application is open-source, supports open standards, and has a good privacy policy, I see little to worry about. The privacy policy, which you can in part confirm through the source code, ensures that your privacy is protected, assuming there are also some reasonable data protection methods in place; and the open standards ensure that you can easily get data in and out of the application, so you don’t have to worry about losing your data or being locked into the application.

I understand the concerns about locking your data into a web application, but we should keep in mind that, as long as you have good open standards and a good privacy policy, (open-source is, of course, good, but not absolutley needed), you don’t have to worry too much about your data.

Related posts:

  1. Open Standards for Cloud Computing We are in an exciting time for technology and cloud...
  2. Open-Source is Privacy Yesterday was data privacy day, according to Lifehacker, and they...
  3. Open Source in the Cloud I have always been a big fan of web (or...
  4. Your Hard Drive in the Cloud Cloud computing may a little over-promised, but it isn’t “worse...
  5. Appcelerator Titanium: Like AIR, But Better A while ago Adobe released Adobe AIR. AIR was a...

2 comments on this post.

  1. RMS makes a consistent point; however, he singled out Gmail and Google has yet to give users anything to worry about over the years it has offered Gmail to the public with regard to privacy. A better argument might simply be one of control. Besides, Gmail lets you transfer your data and content to any other source, keeping its promise that users are allowed to take their data with them when they leave and there’s no lock-in.

  2. Mike B says:

    If you follow his logic we should not use the internet because some bad old profit making company has our email and is using non-open source software.

    Nice job with FOSS but he seems to be growning paranoid. Give him a clean clay tablet and stylus and let him go back to the cave.

Leave a Comment